I've had Catcher in the Eye in the gardens for about five years ... which makes it cold-hardy to zone 3. It's not in the best location, which is why I'm moving it to a new spot this year, but it has bloomed reliably every year.
It's slightly smaller than the stats, both in height and bloom size, but that may be due to location and / or zone. But the applique pattern is unmistakeable and shows up very distinctly even from a distance.
I do think that moving it this year to a better location may give it the boost it needs - when I first put it into the gardens, it was in full sun; but in the past several years, it's fallen under the expanding shade of a nearby oak tree. Moving it back to full sun will, I believe, up the bud count.
That said, it's still a very hardy and healthy daylily, with no issues at all - no pests, no diseases, no rust. If it has not met full expectations then, in my gardens, I would have to say: the fault of poor location is mine.
