I was going to up load a pictures of this but --- Guess what I think I see to different Semps. Have we discussed this and I'm forgetting?

This is mine tonight.

Julia, where did you get yours from? How long have you had it? Is this a recent photo you are showing.
There is a Cherry Frost and a Cherry Frosting.
http://sempervivum-liste.de/ku...
Hen and Chicks (Sempervivum 'Cherry Frosting')
Hen and Chicks (Sempervivum 'Cherry Frost')

These are all pictures form data base. My pictures is from last evening. Mine came from Chris and looks just like her picture. I have had it for about 2 years. Truly a beautiful semp but not covered in velvet like the other two.

@goldfinch4
Chris where did your Cherry Frost come from?
I am thinking that Julia & Chris's semp is really Cherry Frosting, not Cherry Frost.
http://translate.google.com/tr...
http://sempervivum-liste.de/Se...

What do you all think?

I think so too. It was so beautiful last night.

Let's get an answer from Chris then we can proceed from there. I really do think we have a name mix up going on. Looks to be an easy one to fix.

@goldfinch4
Chris I think we have two different semps in this mix. What do you think?
Cherry Frosting
Cherry Frost

Hi there wondering what does the 'real Cherry Frost' look like, does anyone have a picture or written description? @Jungleshadows @Valleylynn
Here are the 2 I have from 2 different sources, I didn't have a quarter so I used my keys to give an idea of size
Photos taken 5/4/2016
From Young's

From SMG


Any info would be great thanks
I'm only just seeing this post - I think the one from PO is correct as it colors up just like what Banker07's looked like. The other one doesn't look like Cherry Frosting, so I think it is just a NOID...let me know what ya'll think. Thanks

I agree that the pictures of mine in the database are wrong - I got rid of that plant a long time ago. The "new" one I have that I think is now the correct ID I bought from PO.

Great photo Chris. I will go remove the incorrect photos.

GREAT TEAM work

I got mine from SMG 3 or 4 years ago, and it looks just like the one from PO.

Okay, I think I got them all. Will all of you go take a look?
Hen and Chicks (Sempervivum 'Cherry Frost')

Cherry Frost is definitely a small cobweb. It was one of Helen's plants that came in as a seedling in a bunch of plants from Sandy MacPherson.

Should have NO velvet either!

Kevin

Kevin, would you look at the ones still in the database entry and tell me which ones do not look correct?
Hen and Chicks (Sempervivum 'Cherry Frost')

Great glad this is resolved! Although now I have the one from Young's - guess I should contact Toby with the info from Kevin...their plant is beautiful it just isn't a small and webby one

Only the one from Twicher looks off.

Compared to newer things in this color range and size it's not too outstanding anyway. That plant is 50 years old!

Kevin

Actually I have just labelled the Young's one NOID and I like it!

Thank you Kevin. I removed that photo now.

Greg, I just went out and checked on my 'Cherry Frost', it is also an incorrect plant. I have turned it's tag and will be using it for gift container planting.

Well there ya go - good idea...I like the one from Young's too much I also have a 'Cherry Tart' which I got from SMG that I know is wrong, but they are pretty and until I somehow magically figure out what they actually are, I'm going to keep it with the label and a "?" (how I label the ones I have that are incorrect!)
Thanks for your help all!