I have had Cherryville here for only three years, so cannot give a thorough evaluation. Also, since it was created not too far from here in North Carolina, evaluation is skewed in it's favor. It has grown really well, two fans planted in separate pots have each increased to two fans. Foliage is bright green and stands up to Winter temps and summer rust very well. It makes a really strong scape that easily tops 30", and is strong enough to support more than one of the heavy flowers. Flowers are super thick substance, sparling texture, full and overlapped, and the clearest, brightest, RED that I have seen on any cultivar. It is in my top 5 best reds without hesitation. Kudos to Vic for this stunning achievement!