Dolly Parton's more of a hot coral color than deep red. It fades to a deeper red, though, almost mauve. And at least you *have* tags! I know all of us has some NOIDs running around in the yard... How old is your deep red? Is it huge? Smelly? if it's a newer rose, it could be Firefighter. If it's older, it could be Oklahoma or Mr. Lincoln. I know they're all deeper red w/huge smelly blooms. At least mine are. When I have blooms, which I'm not having as of late due to a late frickin' snow!!