Hi Kelly.
Most of mine seem to be abundant growers once the new plant gets a nice root system going.
I have very few that don't produce well, one is Gruenrand, a lovely semp but may only make one or two offsets in a season. I have also had problems with Fuzzy Wuzzy (could be our constant rain for 4 months of the year).
It is becoming easier to figure out productivity by going through the database and looking at the photos.
For instance, here is S. 'Leneca' as a new young plant in May of 2011 and again in June of 2012
I would choose photos from the same person for a better comparison, growing conditions are so different. Where do you live? What are your growing conditions like? Growing zone?