I don't use much store-bought stuff in pots, except some mulch when I need it, so not a good one to get involved in a discussion about such, but would be happy to generalize in response. All of my plants are in the same stuff, from Philos to Pentas to Portulaca to Plectranthus. As long as it dries quickly, that should be the main goal, IMVHO. When one can water often/at-will w/o rotting roots, the better. As I'm sure you know, most potted plants are tropical epiphytes, understory jungle plants, or tropical or desert succulents, all of which are unable to cope with dense, airless, soggy, (usually peaty) "soils." (When I got rid of peat completely, it became a rarity for a plant to die here.) Many are used to having partially exposed roots, and an easy time for roots to move through rich rotting humus (or rarely ever get any water at all in the case of desert succulents.) A pot of clay and sand from the ground would have the same detrimental effects on most plants, roots alternating between dessication and rot, and always suffocating from the lack of tiny air particles throughout the pot. For those prone to overwatering (which I would prefer to call under-drying, and includes pretty much everybody who has plants,) it's a huge hardship to try to cope with having plants die because one didn't let them dry out long enough. For the rest of people, they just wonder why their plants aren't as great or as fast-growing as others seem to be, or maybe never make flowers or have great variegation. What's actually happening is that the roots are rotting, and if not dried to recover, the eventual result is death of the plant. Now you still can't take a cactus or jade plant and water it so much that it's drippy wet all of the time, but it's so much easier to change the soil than one's habit of liking to water plants before the precise moment it starts to wilt, which is the only proper time to water something in peat. Too tricky for me, and the plants, IMVHO/E. Many of my hanging baskets of mixed 'annuals' and house plants have been rained on daily, sometimes a few times a day, for the past couple months and nothing in them has died.