Bonehead said: I'll treat it as a foliage plant unless and until it ever deigns to grace me with a bloom. So - move this fall or wait until spring?
Deb, I don't really have experience with peonies yet, but because I'm in love with them I did a lot of research and finally bought two to plant this year.
One of the things I read about them is that they don't really like rich soil, but another site says they prefer rich soil
. They need evenly moist but well-drained soil with a pH close to neutral.
One of the products I've used with great results is MiracleGro Bloom Booster Flower Food. Is it possible that it would be helpful to your peony?
Good luck with it--I hope that you'll have pictures of flowers to show us this spring!