@dave I received a treemail last night and then this morning someone else replied to that treemail and the reply is showing up in my treemail. Are you able to look at treemails after they've been sent? Something appears to be strange.

I am able to dig into the database and most of the data on the site, including tree mails. I took a look and see that you are part of a group tree mail sent by beckygardener to 14 people. Any of those people who reply will be seen by all 14 recipients. That is how group tree mails work.

Gotcha! I think the reply was probably intended to be on the daylily of the day thread, but I expect beckygardener will handle it. Thanks.

Yes, that's probably the case. Becky has been sending these for a while now, and she is clear in the tree mail that replies belong on the thread and not as a reply to the treemail. It's an unfortunate fact that sometimes people don't read everything in front of them and proceed without much attention paid.

Every so often, someone does not completely read the tree-mail and sends me their daylily culitvar performance evaluation via tree-mail instead of posting on the Daylily of the Day thread. I apologize that others see their tree-mail. Just ignore it. I always reply to the member and ask them to post to the thread. And most do!

No problem. I didn't realize there was a 'group tree mail' option. Makes sense since regular email has the option, but I didn't realize it was operable via ATP tree mails. As soon as Dave enlightened my darkened mind, I just ignored it and assumed you would take care of it. I saw when it hit the thread, too.