Do you have Lowes, Wal-mart, or Home Depot near you? Not that it's the best time of year to be looking (they seem to be getting their fall annuals in and their C & S shipments are more of a Spring thing, but they usually have some come in. Wal-Mart (at least for me), can be kind of iffy about succulents, but it's worth a look IMO. I found this one at Wal-Mart:
Sometimes even Bi-lo or Kroger carries them. I want to say Easter is a good time to look too (at least I think that's what purpleinopp told me; my memory is failing me this morning
).