I am Team Water all the way. Nothing attracts birds faster than some water, and I love the sound. In AZ we had big ponds that DH built, and here in Colorado we have our little 'log fountain' and our waterfall (again, both built by DH... I come up with an idea and he makes it so!).
Susie (Aguane), I am so happy that that birdbath still brings you joy... you bring me joy, my friend!