*HIGHLY* Recommend both Melody Parfume & English Perfume. I got MP here at a local nursery and EP from RU. Magenta came from Palatine, FP came as a bodybag (!), BG is a BigBox, Escapade came from RU, Voluptuous! is a bigbox, Natasha Monet & Florence DeLattre came from RU, Othello came from a nursery, & Poseidon came from Palatine. That may help.
I'm getting in Charles de Gaulle from Palatine for the 2013 year and it's supposed to be highly fragrant as well. Some that I've lost were Shocking Blue (ok scent), Lagerfeld (good scent), Stephen's Big Purple (the grandfather of LOTS of blue roses, Good scent). I'm looking for another Shocking Blue again. But I'm keeping your list for the ones I need to get
Oh! I *have* Neptune! I got that this year.. Good scent... forgot...
I remember seeing Spellcaster in the J&P catalog.. was sooooo sorely tempted to buy it but I knew that J&P was sending out crappy plants. I'll have to see if anyone has it ever again.. doesn't look like it.
Oh, just got Hansa, and I know it has a good scent.