Heidi. You will love it here. I have Fooled Me also but its done blooming for me. It would be a safe bet to say yours is indeed Fooled Me. If its store bought in our area they tend to be old and common cultivars such as Night Beacon,Strutters Ball,Mardi Gras Parade, Buttered Popcorn,etc.
A few years back i found Mildred Mitchell at Home Depot and now its one of my favorites.