I believe echoes has the correct Enchantment and Joy's is incorrect. Echoes' photo matches a photo in Ed McRae's book "Lilies: A Guide for Growers and Collectors". 'Enchantment' was hybridized at Oregon Bulb Farms where Ed worked for many years so he would have known the real, original 'Enchantment'.
Enchantment has very crinkly, like pie crust edges and copious spots over a good half of its petals.