Debra, love your white NOID peony! It is the whitest peony that I ever see. My tree peony took 3 years to bloom and I thought it was long. I think your Taiyo is definitely worth the wait.
Tracey, why does JR Double get your first spot? Is it the scent or the form or the color? Like you, Athena is also my top favorite this year, placing at the 4th spot. Although it gave me only 2 small blooms this year, the flower colors are amazing. I can't wait to see it bloom again next year.