Soil Vs Building Material - Knowledgebase Question

Richmond, CA
Question by lmd1938
October 21, 1999
We have clay soil to which I've added alot of compost and other organic material over the years; however, it's still more like adobe, the building material. Is it more practical to just consider the yard as one big clay pot, and while damp, dig a hole, add some potting mix and plant that way, although no drainage would be possible?

Answer from NGA
October 21, 1999


What a sad situation! You've correctly described what would happen if you dug a hole, added potting soil, and planted; you will have created a situation similar to planting in a huge container. However, without adequate drainage, some plants will die a premature death. There are some plants that actually like growing in clay soils and their roots are strong enough to penetrate deeply.

Besides being heavy when wet, and impossible to work when dry, clay soils also incorporate very little air, which can suffocate roots, and they can remain waterlogged for prolonged periods of time, often drowning plants, or at least exposing them to root rotting conditions.

Some of the plants that actually thrive in heavy clay soils include Aster (especially Michaelmas Daisy), Crocosmia, Helenium, Inula, Vibrunum 'Lanarth' (Japanese Snowball), Weigela, Rudbeckia, Boxwood, Spiraea, Forsythia, Hemerocallis, Monarda and Prunella. While these plants won't actually change the soil conditions, they will provide some wonderful spring and summer color!

You must be signed in before you can post questions or answers. Click here to join!

« Return to the Garden Knowledgebase Homepage

Member Login:



[ Join now ]

Today's site banner is by greenappleagnes and is called "Carpenter Bees and Ginger"