So sorry I didn't see this sooner--semp id is too aggravating for me so I avoid it whenever possible--
However, looks like you are not too far south of me and we probably have rather similar conditions, climate anyway albeit different soil.
And, if you are purchasing locally we could even have some of the same misnamed semps
It is often much easier to say that an id is incorrect.
So, with that, I'll say that yours labeled as Rita Jane
11.) 'Rita Jane'
bears a striking resemblance in form (maybe you'll get the color too next spring) to the one that I originally purchased as Rita Jane, but no resemblance to the real Rita Jane.
Here's a link to the post with pics of the imposter as it became a NOID...
I have since acquired the real Rita Jane and this is what she looked like here in early May
See how wide the leaves are in comparison?