Sorry cybersix but if you look on the Daylily database on this site will see that yours does not look much like Always Afternoon. I have grown AA for many years and the first bloom opened today and it is different than yours.
It it an entire clump or one lone scape? Five years ago i sold a pink daylily and apparently did not get all of the root system because last year i had a single bloom shoot out of the side of a clump that did not match the clump. It took 4-5 years for that tiny tuber i left behind to get big enough to bloom. Maybe that is the case. A little detective work can go a long ways.
This is my bloom today. I'd say the color is right but not the eye at all.
