I would second Larry's American Freedom since I just got that one this year, but I have zero zip info on that one because it was one of the last ones I put in the ground. No blooms, nothing....I'll vote for that one sometime next year when I have actually seen it in my yard, I suppose.
My list:
1)
Sir Blackstem - one of the last planted in my garden, but bloomed! - 4 members own this
2)
Jocelyn's Oddity - 4 members own this and 1 wants it
3)
Mynelle's Starfish - 20 members have this
4)
Ginger Twist - 4 members have this
5)
Little Grapette - 36 members have it, 1 wants it
6)
Helix - 17 members have it, 4 want it
7)
Open Hearth - 22 members have it, 2 want it
8)
Absolute Ripper - 6 members have it, 1 wants it
9)
Evening Enchantment - 6 members have it, 1 wants it
10)
Black Plush - 20 members have it, 3 want it
* (...the irony...)
Asterisk only shows that 2 people have it, but I'm willing to bet that more than two have it. There are also two people that want it.
This list is by no means a list of my favorites in my garden, LoL, but I was just trying to think of daylilies in my garden and see if they meet the criteria as I thought of them.