I planted this one 3 years ago. It is a bit disappointing since I paid big bucks for it at a garden centre and now am told it is not Morden Centennial. Any ideas which rose this one is? Fair amount of winter kill in Zone 3. Some canes are 6 feet tall, little over 4 feet wide.

Looks like Morden Centennial that Tagawa's sells here. http://www.helpmefind.com/rose...

Thanks Toni,

I had 2 visitors (both rose experts in the area) and even though they were here at different times, both had thought my Morden Centennial, Linda Campbell and Jens Munk were labelled wrong. I thought I would check since it was the same 3 roses that they had questioned. I do think the Jens Munk is mis-labelled, but from what the folks at ATP have said, it looks like Linda Campbell & Morden Centennial are tagged correctly. I guess my roses look different in my garden then in their own garden

The Calgary Rose Society folks suggest that this rose is Captain Samuel Holland

Do you trust them? Do you want me to move your pictures there?

This one is not a 100% sure, so I don't know what to say. The little metal tag has Morden Centennial, but the people that have seen it say it is not.

Do they mention which characteristics lead them to that conclusion?