On HMF, the Garden Org database, and the Peter Beales rose site, Reine des Violettes is called "shade tolerant". I have a very shady spot, in which Purple Skyliner is growing ,and I'd like to have something with it that starts blooming earlier-this spot is one which meets my eye every day that I go to my garden. Now, being here in Italy, I always figure that if Peter Beales in England calls a rose "shade tolerant",it will most certainly accept shade in my garden. My only doubt is that, on the Peter Beales site, Purple Skyliner is described as tolerating "sun, part-shade or shade" whereas RdV is only tolerant of "sun or part-shade". So, I was just wondering if anyone has RdV growing in the shade, and,if so, just how shady is the spot? Thanks in advance!