These looked like Sedum Burrito (burros tail) to me... Sedum x Rubrotinctum doesn't have farina. IMO.

I would think it nearly impossible to tell burrito from morganianum with propagations that small made from leaves that small to start with. But the color is a better match for those 2 than rubrotinctum, even at that teeny tiny size.

This came off of the plant you didn't think was morganianum. It may not be morganianum but it is definitely not rubrotinctum.

And definitely not burrito.

There was no farina on this. This came from the other plant that somebody has moved all of my pics of, that were uploaded to S. morganianum. This is so much bigger than rubrotinctum, I have several kinds of that.

Is it possible that there are both Sedum burrito/morganianum as well as Harry Butterfield in one pot? I know that Burrito and Morganianum are sometimes sold together, in a single pot.

I don't think so. This is the original pot. I took some of the biggest leaves (a little over an inch long) off of the middle to propagate.

I think the original pic that started this discussion should be moved over with the other Harry Butterfield pics. They are all the same plant. Thanks to all for the help and suggestions on this pic & the others, and sorry for the terse blurts throughout the day. Kept trying to check on plant things & work stuff kept intruding. ; )

Thank you Baja, and Zuzu. : )

I am still doubting that those leaf propagations are from Harry Butterfield, but OK.

Thank you, your comment is on the record. ; )