Hi Laurie!
I came up with my Iris Fragrance Rating system as a way to categorize iris cultivars when I launch my new website this January. Two and a half years ago I decided to start a new online retail iris business, specializing in highly fragrant iris cultivars.
I've been researching, identifying, attempting to locate and acquire those cultivars that are rated as having "Pronounced" fragrance, whether sweet, spicy or just pronounced. I've also been searching through old iris catalogs for original descriptions. Many say things like "Deliciously fragrant!" or "A single flower fills a room with fragrance." Those are what I'm seeking.
I've picked up just a few with pronounced musky but I'm a bit wary of them as I've heard a few people describe them as "offensive". We'll see.
Mostly, I rank fragrance on intensity. I may have to come up with an additional descriptor for particularly pleasing fragrances. Maybe a 5 with an *.
At any rate, here's how it works;
1 = Little or no appreciable fragrance. I will cull these.
2 = Some fragrance but not worth the effort. I will cull these.
3 = You have to bury your nose in the flower to appreciate the fragrance but it's worth it. These are keepers.
4 = The fragrance is noticeable when standing next to the clump.
Definite keepers.
5 = The fragrance finds you! These are valued treasures!
In fact, a few months ago I had the privilege of helping someone identify and locate a 'lost' fragrant iris cultivar. She remembered the iris from "before the 1980s" but didn't know the name and couldn't find anything like it.
I finally came up with 'Song of Gold' (Edward Essig, 1937). She was certain that was it but I couldn't find any vendor listing it. However, the photo credit on the garden.org database listed Melody Masi as the photographer. Fortunately, she has a profile here and I was able to reach her. Melody still grows Song of Gold and was willing to share!
Melody claims the fragrance of Song of Gold would drift through her bedroom window as a child and fill the room with fragrance. I'm eagerly awaiting the first bloom! Sounds like it will be a 5.
So, yeah. It's based pretty much on intensity of fragrance.
Anyway, I'll have my work cut out for me next bloom season as I have a few hundred cultivars to catalog... so far...
Randy