Agree, this question doesn't have a simple answer. Once you get to Z8, you don't have the hurdle of frozen ground to overcome, so what is left for zone-pushing is finding plants that can survive above-ground frost and still keep growing the next year. Using the zone ratings doesn't help much with this because those in warmer zones don't really consider herbaceousness as perennialness so if it's not evergreen, so few people use those plants, the info isn't readily available. They panic if there is frost, while it might be just a normal part of winter farther north. It's just up to individuals to experiment.
A discussion about herbaceous tropical perennials here, with the examples I've found so far. Apparently such an arcane subject, I'm about the only one tracking this kind of thing, at least in this particular discussion:
The thread "Tropical herbaceous perennials" in
Southeast Gardening forum
Since my gardening started in OH, herbaceous perennials are perfectly normal to me. Preferable, really, so I can clearly see the ground over winter to remove baby trees and add leaves/compost.