Brittany,
As you know, I am 'the pot lady' and lots of tender plants are in pots. I do not bring anything indoors.
I either bring them on the patio or I place them under my big trees. If I hear that it will be freezing or below, I bring my
garage sale sheets and I inclose the patio with them to keep the plants there warm and throw some sheets on the plants left in the garden. It might not look pretty , but that is how I avoid killing them and the expense of replacing some tender tropicals.