Tom - your area was part of a glacial lake that whittled down to become Lake Michigan. The limestone is part of the karst topography of your region. The geology of Wisconsin is pretty complex due to areas that were heavily glactiated and other areas that retained pre-glacial features (the Dells area).
So, you have natural lime in your soil, do you have much rot? Of course the amount in the soil might not be enough to be effective.
Which made me wonder about the early spring application that Blyth suggests. He says to use a light sprinkling that will melt away by bloom time. If it is a very light application then it shouldn't change the PH of your soil for any long period of time, especially with spring and summer rain. It will leech out.