Char’s concerns about data integrity are legitimate. People will have to be honest about their motivation and agree to only enter data with honorable intentions. Honor systems can be abused and will not be perfect, but they can and do work.
People will have to be honest about their ability to properly count branches and buds. If they are unsure they should not submit data.
A moderator could watch for and delete “suspicious” data like really odd counts, or counts from a new and unknown user.
The data would go to a "user growing report data" section and not to the official ATP specifications for the cultivar. After some time if enough good data is collected for a cultivar a moderator could decide to update the official ATP specs for the cultivar with the user data.
Because there are quite a few factors that dramatically affect plant performance, performance could vary greatly in the same state, or even same part of a state. So I am still not sure that geographic region (state) is enough. However, if you try to track more of the factors the entry form starts to get long:
You are entering branching and bud performance for hemerocallis cultivar “Cultivar Name”.
Please note the following before continuing:
- Data must only be entered for mature, established clumps.
- No second-hand data. All data must have been actually gathered and verified by you.
- Branching and bud counts must be made accurately and according to AHS guidelines.
- If you are unsure of the accuracy or correctness of your data do not submit it.
Growing season:
Geographic location where plant was grown:
- Country
- State/Province
- Region (Central, N, NE, E, SE, S, SW, W, NW)
Sunlight exposure (select closest match):
- Shade
- Morning sun
- Afternoon sun
- Full day sun
Temperature conditions for the current year until the time data was collected:
Average soil moisture conditions from natural and artificial watering (select condition that most closely matches what the plant generally experienced this growing season):
- Very dry
- Dry
- Moist
- Very moist
- Wet
General existing soil nutrient conditions (including amendments from previous years that provide long-term conditioning):
- Poor soil
- Average soil
- High-quality soil
Soil nutrient conditions from fertilizers/amendments this season:
- No fertilizers/amendments added
- Some fertilizers/amendments added
- Lots of fertilizers/amendments added
Branching Performance:
- Maximum branch count
- Average branch count
- Minimum branch count
Bud count performance:
- Maximum bud count
- Average bud count
- Minimum bud count
Comments
By clicking the submit button I declare that to the best of my knowledge and abilities the above data is true and accurate
Submit