By dave | Almost 4,000 photos were entered in this year's contest - our largest turnout ever! The members all voted for their favorites, and the votes have been tabulated! Click to see the winners! |
tx_flower_child said:Not sure if I understand what you're suggesting but think I do. So do you have a particular design in mind?
Bonehead said:My two cents: keep it as is. I'm not sure exactly who gets the blue ribbon badges, but my thought is they have earned them. Awarding similar badges for lesser prizes is akin to the 'participation trophies' of youth sports these days. We get the pleasure of enjoying all the lovely lovely photographs, then we vote on which ones we like the best (difficult task), then the winners get the distinction of displaying (or not) their blue ribbon award. I'd like to not see that get watered down.
Bonehead said:
I guess I also have to question your statement that "All contests have something that acknowledges the first, second and third place winners." On what do you base this?
Bonehead said:Well, OK. That has about nothing to do with photography or gardening. Again, not trying to pick a fight, but...? Confused.
Bonehead said:And perhaps I'm just further confused - what would be the point of acknowledging 2nd and 3rd place winners? A feather in the cap? Since we are limited to 12 visible badges, my inclination is to focus on my personal interests. But, that's me.
fwmosher said:I am only new to this blog and I like it, and its members/contributors very much. Can barely wait for new postings through my cold winter months. However, in my humble opinion, I do not think that second and third place finishers should receive a special symbol! I won a first place, and I didn't even get an acorn. LOL. I'm not complaining! (not sure how you get acorns anyway). LOL. Look, as we are now doing, let's continue to submit photos judged by our membership on the photo merits, including second and third place. I think the present system will make us try harder! I know I certainly am going to do so for the next contest! Personally, I don't even think the "Best in Show" awards should be granted. It is a little too "Dog Show" style (and I have been there done that many times in the past)! Great photos submitted!!! Even contacted a bunch of submitters to congratulate same, and ask questions about various plants/places in their pictures. Also had a member, quite rudely ask me if my submission was "the same one that had been shopped around on various sites?" Hey, still a great photo contest, great membership, great blog! Don't change anything! Cameras at the ready, hello 2018! Cheers from Nova Scotia.
tx_flower_child said:I'm in the 'no badges for 2nd and 3rd place winners' category. Just saying. Not really posting to debate. I'm posting because I want to toss an acorn or two to get @fwmosher started gathering some.
Hmm. Now I'll have to see if there's a more direct route for tossing acorns.
tx_flower_child said:Actually Bob's my brother.
What I meant by directly tossing an acorn was if one could be tossed without attaching it to a post. Just aim it at the intended recipient and throw. I'll have to read the instructions. Might help!