Kristy is that a real toad in there?
I used to have about 6 ceramic brightly painted mushrooms that I really liked. However I didn't bring them in the house last winter and they were all badly damaged so I pitched them. I bought each of them on sale for $20 or less. I probably won't replace them because they really didn't fit in that well. Now I'm leaning more towards stone and metal for garden art pieces.
I have not put out my other pieces of garden art for the year yet - they include a granite owl, a bronze sundial on a stand and a small copper birdbath on a slender stand. Each of those pieces varied in price from $50-$150.