I have made homemade concoctions using all ingredients you mentioned and none ever attracted other wildlife. The only product I ever used that DID attract unwelcome wildlife was fish emulsion, which is used in making the Hooker solution. Whew. That stuff smelled NASTY, and I quit using it after finding it attracted skunks. The skunks proceeded to dig in/ around garden areas looking for fish. Sad to say, none of these homemade concoctions worked very well or very long for me, which is why my garden now has an 8' deer fence. If I had all the $$$ spent over a 15 year period fighting the deer, it probably would have paid for at least half of the fence!!
