It is always uncomfortably for me to questions a plant. I am always afraid I might offend some one. I sure don't want to do that. You all are like the best ever plant family, EVER!
And it is some times fun to track down the real semp. When we get this one figured out I will add a written description of the plant to the database entry, then send the incorrect photos to the Generic sempervivum entry. That way we won't lose the photos in the threads.