Heidi--You have a white elephant in your garden! If you can not see it's redeeming factor and no one gives you a reason you had not thought of. I would get rid of it. The only reason I can think of is that it would make every other daylily look good.
if you like the color get George Caleb Bingham, he is only slightly twisted. Seriously, it is hard to part with plants, they are alive, and I think our inner hope button kicks in. Gardeners are a people that do not like to give up. Thank God for all your other beauties and toss this one! May joy follow us wherever we go.