Jane ~ I couldn't answer that question as many irises, as you know, cannot be judged on their first year's performance. I may be pleasantly surprised next spring. I was debating at first, and then decided to give it another chance.
I probably don't have a lot of years left, so I am trying to get this "iris garden" organized and make some crosses. Many will be tossed (seedlings), and others donated to various groups and members. It is so rare to find a passion so late in life. I feel truly blessed to have the space and the support from loved ones and this wonderful iris group.
Still, I really want to only keep the best performers, so time will tell. On the other hand, it is quite impressive if the irises bloom well and increase in their first year. That is always a plus.