#1 I like the ruffling. It is, for lack of a better word, a tight ruffling. I'm not fond of the color of the self. If the edge was the only thing going for it though it would have to go.
#2 I'm only dabbling in doubles, but I might keep this because it has the little teeth and see if I could get a little bit larger teeth on it. To me the color is muddy (some people like those muddy colors) and I have a double I would take it to to see if I could make the color more clear.
#4 I like the teeth and hooks (?) If the plant habits are good I would keep it.
#5 I'm an eye and edge kind of person. I love how the petals look like they are sitting slighty above the sepals and not resting on them. I also like that the sepals are narrower. I would put a pattern on this to see if I could break up the eye.
#8 I just absolutely love this one. I may be wrong (it could be the lighting) but it seems to have a pink undertone to it. A lot of whites have a yellow undertone. And the edge is fantastic. I would take this to a couple of near white UFs I have
If I could only keep couple though I would keep #5 and #8
