Thank you Rick, as usual, your common sense prevails. I did have a bad aphid issue on all my lilies last year, the first aphids I've had at this location. I'm monitoring them really close, I already have aphids on my tomatoes and have used insecticidal soap on them. Would this be ok for the lilies? And I just can't bear the thought of pulling these lilies up, they're so sweetly fragrant and so very pretty. I didn't mind that I pulled up the tigers, they're certainly not my favorites. Here's one of my asiatics that's blooming now. Really shines, I do love this one.