I have one from 2002, and one from 2018, and I think the older one is more fragrant, but it doesn't compare to "fruity" fragrant ones like Fragrant Cloud. My Sunset book calls it "sweetly scented." When I asked a Weeks representative about the older one being more fragrant, he said that they are recommending Sedona as a replacement. Sedona I've found is more fragrant, but also a slightly different color (yellow in the center.)