Caroline--my final selection ended up very different than what I started with also!!! I finally just ran out of time and made some quick decisions.
My list includes:
Pineapple
Sungold
Margeurite
Goose Creek
Black from Tula
Pork Chop
Mary Robinson's German
Orange Minsk
Top SIrloin
Cherokee Purple
At least, I think that's my list
I try to grow something of each color--I like variety, and try something new every year. The only repeat on this list is Goose Creek--I grew it last year and loved the few tomatoes I got from it. But, it was a dismal tomato year last year so couldn't really give it a fair trial.