Kate, I do like your avatar too!!
Cruddy, yep, that can happen, and its challenging because they can look different when they're small rosettes. I usually order more than one order of each plant and there have been several times where they all look the same except for one! I haven't had them long enough to see if that one ever ends up looking more like the others. Also I tend to use the odd looking ones for projects where they get mixed in and become NOIDs.
Glad you got that sorted out though, and Fuego looks so nice! Its one I want too! - oh yeah, forgot I pretty much want them all, even though space is limited!