Nice seedlings Michele, I would certainly keep the last one a while longer, with that parentage, bud count and branching you should get some great babies from it. The teeth on the first one may improve with later blooms and rebloom.
This is also two that surprised me from this cross.
Both are about 7"
LILLIAN KATHLEEN X LOOPY LOO
"
HB42 X (LILLIAN'S JINGER BRED X BEST EDGE) Both are about 6"
(EMMAS CURLS X FRED MANNING) X BONIBRAE THE FREAK 7-8"??
LILLIAN'S WOMANS TOUCH X EMERALD STARBURST 4"
