Cindi - Only problem with Madame Hardy & Madame Plantier is that they're once bloomers... and if you put them w/a lilac, you've got a hell of a show for 2 weeks, then boredom for the rest of the year.
Only time I've seen Lady X it didn't have a scent. And promptly croaked on me. LOLLL..
Poseidon is a definite favorite of mine. Magenta is also a VERY good rose. And I'm glad that you're having problems with Red Intuition. Mine died 100% to the ground & I never saw anything this spring.. I don't even know 100% exactly where it's planted. I actually lost a couple of Palatine's this year. Garden Delight & Charles de Gaulle both croaked... Tatton, Moody Blue, those two are barely hanging on. And, to be perfectly honest, I have NO idea where half of my others are at! They didn't bloom this year, so I don't know. I really need to wander around & find them... but it's been so darned hot and mosquito-filled, that's why I've been so reluctant to go outside for the past month! Hate being eaten alive!!