Okay all of you semp sleuths. Time to take a look at S. 'Circus', hybridizer is Ed Skrocki 1976.
Here is a quote from Kevin: "I remember it as more like 'Plastic' and the decription in Helen's catalog agrees with that idea too."
Here is what we have in the ATP database:
Hen and Chicks (Sempervivum 'Circus')
Is Circus suppose to be smooth leaved, or fuzzy leaved?
@JungleShadows @banker07 @goldfinch4 @twitcher and anyone else that would like to help solve this mystery.