I absolutely love 'Do Tell'. Mine blooms prolifically and is a very pale pink which contrasts beautifully with the deep pink center!
I think it is much prettier than the picture in the Rogers peony book! I have never noticed that the petals fall off early... It hasn't bloomed yet this year so I will have to watch for that when it blooms. I also discovered a seedling a few feet away which I think is from Do Tell, but it is a darker pink without as much contrast that I like so much. This is the 3rd year for "Do Tell Jr." (my name) and is a bigger clump with more buds so I am anxious to see it again!