I like A&D a lot, Lily. Their roots are comparable to Adelmans, Swensons and Hollingsworths. The guys that run it are very helpful as well and they tend to send a bonus root if you order a few. I'm with you--the discount wasn't enough to make me want to order more. I'm going to be squeezing in just to get the rest of the ones I've already ordered planted!
Yan, I'm sorry! My order from Chateau CharMarron was delayed in shipment while she waited for one of my selections to arrive at her location. I was under the impression that she was a grower and that all of the roots she offered were grown there, dug and shipped like the rest of the big growers, guess that's not the case for all of her herbaceous roots. I've heard really good things about her tree peonies, though.
So my Hollingsworth order came in today! Here's what I got:
Artemis
Bernice Carr
Color Magnet
Dr JH Neeley
Early Canary
Marilla Beauty
Old Faithful (this was a bonus root!)
