Startle was a slow starter for me but every year has been a little better. I agree with Cindy that it has some years that are better than others. Some years the edges are a lot more toothy than others and the color is more intense. For me, in zone 3, it is a late bloomer and sometimes it is still blooming when we have a hard frost so doesn't have time here to get seed ripe. It does get blotchy when we have very cool mornings and heavy dew as do many of my daylilies.
More teeth year.
Blotchy from heavy dew.
This year.