I have Forty Second Street, and that is not it. I'm amazed at how many daylilies I have been sold that are not what they are said to be. I guess we just have to chalk it up to being human and either forgetful or so busy digging and potting that we sometimes forget what is what.
I was sold this deep cherry red spider as "Once In a Blue Moon", which it is not! If anyone has an idea of what this could be, please let me know. This is its 2nd year growing in my garden and it was only about 28" tall, but the flower is at least 11" wide.