I'm looking for a distinctive and sturdy rose here in my garden in the Loch Lomond National Park in Scotland.
We have lots of rain so rain resistance would be a desirable quality.
I have been looking at Independence Day, Texas Centennial and Herbert Hoover - said to be good for displays and with a great fragrance.
I have an American Pillar rose and am delighted with it, though I gave it precautionary sprays in the spring against black spot.
The garden is quite sheltered, in a most romantic part of Scotland, it faces south, and has spectacular views to Loch Earn. There are more than 50 roses to look after. Colour matters less than ability to maintain shape. Fragrance also appreciated!
Bill in Rob Roy country.

You already ask this question a few days ago. It's not a good idea to keep starting a new thread for the exact same question. You had one response from zuzu.

The thread "best american rose ideas, please!" in Ask a Question forum

If you want to bump your question up nearer the top of the list, just post in your original thread something like "still looking for suggestions." And that way, all your responses will be in the same thread.

And if you can't find that original thread, click on your profile, either your member name in your post or the the 'person' icon at the top left in the blue section, and then click on the 'view posts by...