I guess I have to say I'm a combination of both ... some jobs are "Team Gloves" while others are "Bare Hands". I have to wear gloves when shoveling or raking because of the blister thing and when using the old wheel barrow because of splinters! When planting I sometimes start out wearing gloves to try to keep my hands clean, but within minutes the gloves are off and I'm bare handed ... there's a permanent spot by the kitchen sink that holds a scrub brush and a bar of "Gardeners Hand Soap" for my nails!
On occasion I go for a manicure and pedicure ... and the next day I wonder why I wasted my money because I'm right back outside bare handed and barefoot!