Vickie - Looking at the photos in the database, I can actually see a bloom difference in the photos of each cultivar:
Witch Stitchery -
Daylily (Hemerocallis 'Witch Stitchery')
Paper Butterfly -
Daylily (Hemerocallis 'Paper Butterfly')
It doesn't help that Paper Butterfly is the pollen parent of Witch Stitchery.
To my eyes, Witch Stitchery has a smaller eye zone than Paper Butterfly.
It looks like you have 2 Paper Butterfly plants, to my eyes. Which is not all bad, because I love Paper Butterfly and can't wait until mine grows large enough to divide and plant more around my garden areas. (If it survives here ....) It also makes a good parent for hybridizing.
My Paper Butterfly (I do not have Witch Stitchery):
They have the same hybridizer, too.
