Hi
@Succulentnewbie and welcome to our forum! I'm also a Wisconsinite (Ripon)!
Lynn's advice is spot-on. They're really outdoor plants and will survive our winters fine being outside as long as they have good drainage. What I would do is repot them, but make sure you put some type of grit in your potting soil. I mix chicken grit in mine. Then if you have a window that gets morning sun, it would help to place them on that windowsill. That way they'll get good sun and also benefit from the cooler temperature by the window. In the spring slowly acclimate them to the outdoors.
