It does indeed look like that one. I have sent the seller an Email asking for clarification. We shall see what he says.
One thing that I can test when they bloom is ploidy. It seems that Chocolate Splash is a Tet, while Chocolate Dreams is a Dip. That should be easy enought to figure out.
I have checked my records further and realized that I actually bought "Chocolate Dreams" twice from different people. I know that I planted both purchases together to make a bigger clump. If I actually received different cultivars from each seller that would certainly explain the mixed clump.
After looking at pictures from the Shooter's site I am now wondering if the other plant I have is actually Chocolate Dreams either. It actually looks more like the picture of Chocolate Ripples to me.
http://www.mariettagardens.com...
Daylily (Hemerocallis 'Chocolate Ripples')
What do you guys think?