Oh, they win hands down. I have four different Oaks here and save all the leaves I can except not so much from the Burr Oak--which don't seem to hold up quite as well. We pile them all up on an 18 X 24 tarp and we fold it up like big canoe and slide them down to my holding area. I get about three loads. Might not think so, but leaves are pretty heavy in that quantity. Two people have all they can do just sliding it along-- but the procedure works very well.